lifestyle with leah headshot
Hello! I'm Leah.
  • About Me
  • Say Hello
  • Work With Me
  • Home
  • About
    • Meet Leah
    • Privacy Policy
    • Disclosure
    • Contact
  • Resources
    • How to Start a Blog
    • Income Reports
    • Printables
  • Subscribe
  • Shop
    • Recommended Products
    • Gift Guides
    • Online Courses
    • Amazon Storefront
    • LTK
    • Etsy
    • My Shop

Lifestyle with Leah

  • Holiday
    • Christmas
    • Easter
    • Fourth of July
    • Halloween
    • New Year
    • St. Patrick’s Day
    • Thanksgiving
    • Valentine’s Day
  • Recipes
    • Ninja Creami
    • Holiday
    • Breakfast
    • Snacks
    • Dinner
    • Dessert
    • Drinks
  • Crafts
    • Crafts
    • IG Story Templates
  • Travel
    • Domestic Travel
    • International Travel
  • Lifestyle
    • Beauty
      • Nails
    • Family
    • Fashion
  • Wellness
    • Essential Oils
    • Health + Fitness
    • Nutrition
    • Tips & Tricks

Blog, Ninja Creami, Recipes · March 21, 2025

Ninja Creami Cake Batter Ice Cream

Jump to Recipe

Learn how to make yummy Ninja Creami cake batter ice cream! This fun cake batter ice cream recipe is easy to whip up and perfect when craving a sweet treat!

Content may contain affiliate links. When you shop the links, we receive a small commission at no cost to you. Thanks for supporting Lifestyle with Leah!

Are you a cake batter ice cream lover?

If you want to know the truth, I would never order it at an ice cream store…but this recipe is SO GOOD!

cake batter ice cream recipe

I love a good yellow cake with rainbow sprinkles and this one tasted so much like it.

It’s also super pretty, creamy, and delicious.

Ninja Creami links are found on my Amazon Shop Page!

It’s like a funfetti ice cream but with extra protein and a lot less guilt!

Reasons to Love This Homemade Cake Batter Recipe

MIX-INS

Who doesn’t love rainbow sprinkles?! Especially kids. This colorful pop makes the ice cream that much better

HEALTHIER DESSERT OPTION

Making a Ninja Creami is a great option to replace ice cream because it tastes just like regular ice cream (dare I say, even creamier) but it’s a healthier option for you.

ALLERGY-FRIENDLY

This ice cream is nut-free, gluten-free, egg-free, and can be made dairy-free depending on the milk of choice. *Make sure to check your rainbow sprinkle ingredients to ensure they are allergy-free if needed.

cake batter ice cream

Where To Get the Ninja Creami

I got mine off of Amazon (during Prime Day) and it was the best purchase ever.

Not only are the deals great, but I got it within 2 days of ordering it.

They also now have a soft-serve version called the Ninja Swirl which I’ve been eyeing for next Prime Day!

Why Should You Get a Ninja Creami

Let’s talk about my favorite kitchen product, the Ninja Creami.

I love ice cream so much.

As much as I love indulging in a big bowl of ice cream, I wanted a way to enjoy my favorite treat without feeling so guilty when my bowl was empty.

That’s when I started seeing the Ninja Creami all over social media,

I knew I had to give it a try—and let me tell you, it lives up to the hype!

If you don’t believe me, try one of my Ninja Creami recipes and get back to me.

Other Ninja Creami Recipes

strawberry cheesecake ninja creami
STRAWBERRY
CHEESECAKE
chocolate chip cookie ice cream
CHOCOLATE CHIP
COOKIE
ninja creami lemon
LEMON WITH
GRAHAM CRACKERS

How is Ninja Creami Ice Cream Healthier?

The Ninja Creami is known to be a healthier version of ice cream because it uses fewer and cleaner ingredients, and you can control exactly what goes into the recipe.

Say goodbye to artificial additives and processed sugars and hello to high-protein bases like Greek yogurt, Fairlife milk (a favorite), cottage cheese, or protein powders, making it a more nutritious option.

What Kind of Protein Powder to Use?

The only protein powder I use in my Ninja Creami recipes Clean Simple Eats.

I love it because it contains 20g of protein, includes a digestive enzyme blend, and is made with natural ingredients that actually taste good.

vanilla cake batter ice cream ninja creami

Trust me, tons of friends told me they can’t believe how good it tastes.

If you’re looking to try it, use code LEAHF on the Clean Simple Eats website for 10% off your order!

They offer a variety of delicious flavors and even have sample packs, so you can find your favorite before committing to a full size.

Ingredients to Make Cake Batter Ice Cream

MILK

Fairlife milk is my go-to because it has 13g of protein per serving. For this particular recipe I used 2% Fairlife Milk. 2% milk.

It also creates a creamy texture in the ice cream.

ice cream batter recipe

PROTEIN POWDER

For this recipe, you’ll need cake batter protein powder, and my favorite is from Clean Simple Eats.

Each serving contains 20g of protein and it’s made with natural ingredients and includes a digestive enzyme blend for easy digestion.

Use code LEAHF on the Clean Simple Eats website for 10% off your order!

They have tons of flavors, and if you’re unsure which one to try, they also offer sample packs.

SUGAR-FREE PUDDING MIX

A pudding mix enhances the sweetness. I use 1-2 tbsp, in each Ninja Creami recipe.

For this recipe I used a sugar-free vanilla pudding mix.

MIX-INS

To make this cake batter ice cream even yummier, I added in rainbow sprinkles for the mix-ins.

They went inside the ice cream and as a topping.

How to Make Cake Batter Ice Cream

best cake batter ice cream
yellow cake batter ice cream
ninja cream cake batter

Take your Ninja Creami pint container and fill it with all the ingredients except the sprinkles.

Next, take your frother and froth until all are combined. If you do not have a frother you can use a blender.

Freeze the mix for 24 hours.

ninja creami cake batter ice cream
how to make cake batter ice cream
cake batter ice cream near me

Take the container out and put it into the Ninja Creami and then blend on “Lite Ice Cream.”

If it has a nice creamy texture skip the next step. However, if the ice cream looks crumbly, make a hole in the middle and add about 1-2 tsp. of milk.

cake batter ice cream ben and jerry

Put it back in the machine and hit “re-spin”.

When it’s done add in some sprinkles. Then hit “mix-ins”.Top with some more of the sprinkles.

Enjoy your Ninja Creami Cake Batter Ice Cream!

Tips for Making the Best Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream

Protein Powder: Clean Simple Eats is the protein powder I would recommend using. So incredibly flavorful and filled with clean ingredients and contains tons of protein. I have a 10% off code for you here.

Blend Blend Blend: You want to make sure you blend all ingredients completely so you have a smooth and creamy base. You can either use a frother or blender. Frother is less clean up though!

Freeze Time: Make sure you have the Ninja Creami mix entirely frozen for no shorter than 8 hours or up to 24 hours if you have the patience. This will give it the best consistency!

Run Pint Under Warm Water: Right before you mix it in the Ninja Creami, run the pint jar under warm water so the sides and bottom of the pint aren’t icy. I do this for about 2-3 minutes. Another option is to set it out for 5-10 minutes before mixing.

Re-Spin Tip: Now, this doesn’t happen every time but if your ice cream is too hard or crumbly after the first spin, you can either just respin again to see if it gets creamy or add 1-2 tbsp. of milk in the middle and respin.

Serve Immediately: The ice cream has the best texture right after it’s been mixed. If you want to have leftovers be sure to run under warm water and spin again before eating. Keep in mind the texture will be a little different, but still delicious!

cake batter ice cream cold stone

Nutrition Facts for Cake Batter Ice Cream

This is why I love the Ninja Creami so much.

In a regular Cake Batter ice cream the calories, carbs and fats would be doubled (or even tripled) and the protein would be cut in half!

NUTrition Facts: 265 calories | 33g. protein | 16g. carbs | 6g. fat

*The nutrition information provided is calculated based on My Fitness Pal and should be used as a general guide only.

Recommended Equipment + Products

Ninja CREAMI Mixer

Pint Containers

Protein Powder

cake batter ice cream recipe

Want Even More Ninja Creami Recipes?

Snickerdoodle Ninja Creami

Strawberry Cheesecake Ninja Creami

Chocolate Peanut Butter Ninja Creami

Lemon Ninja Creami

Pistachio Ninja Creami

Cookies ‘N Creme Ninja Creami 

cake batter ice cream recipe
Print

Cake Batter Ice Cream (Ninja Creami)

Course Dessert
Keyword cake batter, Ice Cream, ninja creami
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 1 day
Total Time 1 day 5 minutes
Servings 1

Ingredients

  • 1 cup Fairlife 2% Milk
  • 1 scoop Cake Batter Protein Powder *I use Clean Simple Eats
  • 2 tbsp. Sugar-Free Vanilla Pudding Mix
  • 1 tsp. Sprinkles

Instructions

  1. Take your Ninja Creami pint container and fill it with all the ingredients except the sprinkles.

  2. Next, take your frother and froth until all are combined. If you do not have a frother you can use a blender.

  3. Freeze the mix for 24 hours.

  4. Take the container out and put it into the Ninja Creami and then blend on “Lite Ice Cream.”

  5. If it has a nice creamy texture skip the next step. However, if the ice cream looks crumbly, make a hole in the middle and add about 1-2 tsp. of milk.

  6. Put it back in the machine and hit “re-spin”.

  7. When it’s done add in some sprinkles. Then hit “mix-ins”.

  8. Top with some more of the sprinkles and enjoy!

Pin for Later!

Posted In: Blog, Ninja Creami, Recipes

Get on the List

You’ll Also Love

My Morning and Nighttime Skincare Routine
used designer bags websiteDesigner Bags for Less: Shop Authentic Designer Bags at Working Girls Boutique
Blackstone Griddle Recipes for Beginners13 Absolutely Delicious Blackstone Griddle Recipes to Make!

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Next Post >

10 Beautiful Charcuterie Boards to Make This Spring

About Me
Welcome to my favorite space, my little corner of the internet where you can pour a hot cup of coffee (or your favorite drink), sit back and spend some time with me!

Cheers!

amazon disclaimer

Leah is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Stay Updated

Featured

Archives

Categories

  • Gift Guides
  • Lifestyle
  • Recipes
  • Wellness

Search

hey there!

Why hello friend! Thanks so much for stopping by and taking the time to get to know me. My name is Leah and I am the girl behind the blog, Lifestyle with Leah. I am also a wife, mommy of two girls, and a serious lover of coffee and red wine. On this blog, I share all of my favorites… family, wellness, recipes, essential oils, tips and tricks, you name it… it’s probably on here! Enjoy!

Work With Me

  • Services
  • Meet Leah
  • Contact

Resources

  • Resources
  • How to Start a Blog
  • Income Reports

Shop

  • Amazon Storefront
  • LTK
  • Etsy
  • Terms and Conditions

Copyright © 2026 Lifestyle with Leah · Theme by 17th Avenue

Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy