lifestyle with leah headshot
Hello! I'm Leah.
  • About Me
  • Say Hello
  • Work With Me
  • Home
  • About
    • Meet Leah
    • Privacy Policy
    • Disclosure
    • Contact
  • Resources
    • How to Start a Blog
    • Income Reports
    • Printables
  • Subscribe
  • Shop
    • Recommended Products
    • Gift Guides
    • Online Courses
    • Amazon Storefront
    • LTK
    • Etsy
    • My Shop

Lifestyle with Leah

  • Holiday
    • Christmas
    • Easter
    • Fourth of July
    • Halloween
    • New Year
    • St. Patrick’s Day
    • Thanksgiving
    • Valentine’s Day
  • Recipes
    • Ninja Creami
    • Holiday
    • Breakfast
    • Snacks
    • Dinner
    • Dessert
    • Drinks
  • Crafts
    • Crafts
    • IG Story Templates
  • Travel
    • Domestic Travel
    • International Travel
  • Lifestyle
    • Beauty
      • Nails
    • Family
    • Fashion
  • Wellness
    • Essential Oils
    • Health + Fitness
    • Nutrition
    • Tips & Tricks

Blog, Ninja Creami, Recipes · April 2, 2025

Butterscotch Ice Cream Recipe in the Ninja Creami

Jump to Recipe

Learn how to make this Butterscotch Ice Cream recipe at home using the Ninja Creami. With a luxuriously smooth texture and nostalgic gourmet flavor, each spoonful is a taste of heaven!

Content may contain affiliate links. When you shop the links, we receive a small commission at no cost to you. Thanks for supporting Lifestyle with Leah!

butterscotch ninja creami recipe

This isn’t your average scoop of ice cream—this is rich, creamy Butterscotch Ice Cream made in the Ninja Creami.

This recipe is all about that deep, buttery butterscotch flavor that melts in your mouth.

All the links to the Ninja Creami + Accessories are found on my Amazon Shop Page here!

We are headed to The Wizarding World of Harry Potter this month so of course I had to make butterscotch-flavored ice cream in the Ninja Creami to remind me of Butterbeer!

Of course, it won’t be the same but it’s good enough for me.

Why You’ll Love This Butterscotch Ice Cream Recipe

SILKY, CREAMY TEXTURE
The smooth butterscotch base takes the texture to the next level.

A BETTER-FOR-YOU INDULGENCE
Made with simple ingredients and packed with protein, this Ninja Creami recipe lets you enjoy dessert without the guilt.

ALLERGY-FRIENDLY OPTIONS
This recipe is easy to customize to be nut-free, gluten-free, egg-free, and even dairy-free depending on the milk base you choose.

A CROWD-PLEASER FOR ALL AGES
Whether you’re whipping it up for your kids, guests, or just a cozy night in, this butterscotch ice cream hits that nostalgic sweet spot with an elevated twist.

how to make butterscotch ice cream

Where To Get the Ninja Creami

You can either grab a Ninja Creami from the Ninja Creami website or you can get it off Amazon!

Amazon has a ton of sales throughout the year and I snagged my Ninja Creami off of Prime Day and got it within two days.

Can’t beat that!

Why Should You Get a Ninja Creami

Ice cream has always been my all-time favorite food (yes, it counts!), but I wasn’t a fan of how high the sugar and fat content are.

Even when you get ice cream in the store that is “better for you” it either tastes too icy, watery down, or has no flavor.

I wanted a way to still enjoy those creamy delicious bowls of ice cream without the guilt, and that’s when I kept seeing the Ninja Creami pop up—everyone was raving about it for making healthy, high-protein ice cream at home. I finally gave it a try, and honestly? It’s the best.

Now I can make thick, creamy, and healthier ice cream in minutes with simple ingredients—no weird texture, no compromise on flavor, just a whole lotta yummy.

How is Ninja Creami Ice Cream Healthier?

The Ninja Creami uses minimal ingredients, and I am able to control exactly what goes into it.

I can put a little bit of pudding mix or a lot of pudding mix, I can also control the toppings, and how much or how little to put in.

Another reason it is healthier is because I use high-protein bases like Greek yogurt, Fairlife milk (a favorite), cottage cheese, or protein powders, instead of cream and sugar.

Other Ninja Creami Recipes

snickerdoodle cookie dough ice cream
SNICKERDOODLE
cake batter ice cream recipe
CAKE BATTER
chocolate chip cookie ice cream
CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE

Which Protein Powder is Best to Use?

This was quite the task.

I have tried so many different protein powders out there that were full of chemicals, tasted gross or had that chalky texture.

However, the one I stumbled upon and fell in love with is Clean Simple Eats.

Clean Simple Eats is the only protein powder I use in my Ninja Creami recipes. It has 20g of protein per serving, a digestive enzyme blend to keep things easy on your stomach, and clean ingredients that actually taste amazing.

best butterscotch ice cream

I’ve recommended this brand to so many friends and family members and they all agree with me.

If you want to give Clean Simple Eats it a try, you can use code LEAHF for 10% off on the Clean Simple Eats website!

They’ve got tons of great flavors and even sample packs so you can test a few before committing to a full size.

Ingredients for the Butterscotch Ice Cream Recipe

The ingredients below are exactly how I made my butterscotch ice cream in the Ninja Creami. You can get the full printable list down below.

butterscotch ripple ice cream

MILK

For all my Ninja Creami creations, I use for Fairlife 2% milk. It’s my go-to because each serving packs 13g of protein, which gives the ice cream a nutritional boost without sacrificing taste. Plus, it creates that rich, creamy texture we all love—no need for heavy cream or a bunch of unnecessary additives.

PROTEIN POWDER

When it comes to protein powder, I’m super picky—and Clean Simple Eats is hands down my favorite. For this recipe, I use their vanilla protein powder called “Simply Vanilla”, which delivers 20g of protein per serving.

Use code LEAHF for 10% off on the Clean Simple Eats website!

Not only does it taste amazing, but it’s also made with clean, natural ingredients and includes a digestive enzyme blend, making it easier on your stomach.

SUGAR-FREE PUDDING MIX

To sweeten things up and enhance that rich flavor, I like to add a little sugar-free butterscotch pudding mix. I usually go with 2 tablespoons but for this particular recipe I just used one, Pudding mix gives just the right amount of sweetness—but you can adjust based on your personal taste.

SYRUP

I usually skip syrups when making my Ninja Creami recipes, but this time I decided to experiment a little—and I’m glad I did. I added a splash of Jordan’s Skinny Gourmet Sugar-Free Caramel Syrup, and it gave the ice cream just the right hint of caramel without adding any extra sugar. It was a fun way to switch things up and brought a little more depth to the butterscotch flavor. I typically use this syrup in my morning coffee, so I already knew I loved the taste. But it worked surprisingly well in the ice cream too—definitely a new trick I’ll keep in my back pocket!

MIX-INS

For this recipe, I decided to skip the mix-ins to keep the macros in check—but if you’re looking to level it up a bit, I’ve got a few fun ideas! Try adding butterscotch chips or a drizzle of caramel sauce for that extra indulgent touch.

How to Make the Butterscotch Ice Cream Recipe

Take a Ninja Creami pint container and fill it up with all the ingredients.

butterscotch ice cream ninja creami
where to buy butterscotch ice cream
butterscotch ice cream indian

Next, take your frother and froth until all are combined. If you do not have a frother you can use a blender.

Freeze the mix for about 8-24 hours.

butterscotch ice cream recipe
butterscotch ice cream near me

Take the container out run it under warm water for 1-2 minutes.

Put the pint into the Ninja Creami and then blend on “Lite Ice Cream.”

Remove from the Ninja Creami and check to see what it looks like. If it has a more powdery look then put it back into the machine and hit “re-spin”.

butterscotch ice cream cone
butterscotch ice cream price
butterscotch ice cream topping

Check the ice cream again as the final product should look creamy! If you need to re-spin now is the time.

Also, if you decide to add mix-ins you can make a hole in the middle, add your mix-ins and put the pint back into the machine and hit “mix-ins”.

Enjoy!

Tips for Making the Best Ninja Creami Protein Ice Cream

Choose the Right Protein Powder:
I’ve tested a lot of protein powders, and Clean Simple Eats is hands down my favorite. It’s packed with protein, made with clean ingredients, and actually tastes good—which is hard to find. If you want to give it a try, you can grab it with code LEAHF for 10% off!

Blend Thoroughly:
To get that perfectly creamy texture, make sure you’re blending your base really well before freezing. You can use a blender or even a handheld frother (my go-to when I’m trying to cut down on dishes). The goal is a smooth, lump-free mix that freezes evenly.

Freeze Completely:
Don’t rush this part—your mixture should be frozen solid before spinning. I recommend freezing for at least 8 hours, but overnight (closer to 24 hours) gives the best results in my experience.

Warm the Pint Before Spinning:
Right before you run your mix through the Ninja Creami, hold the pint under warm water for a few minutes (I usually do 1-3 minutes). This helps soften the edges and prevent icy chunks. Alternatively, let it sit out at room temp for 5–10 minutes.

Don’t Stress the First Spin:
Sometimes it comes out perfect on the first spin, and sometimes it needs a little help. If your ice cream is crumbly or too firm, just respin it—either as is or with a splash (1–2 tablespoons) of milk added to the center.

Best Served Fresh:
The texture is chef’s kiss right after mixing, so I always recommend enjoying it right away. If you do save some for later, just let it soften a bit and respin before eating—it might be slightly different in texture but still totally worth it.

butterscotch ninja creami recipe

Nutrition Facts for Cake Batter Ice Cream

Keep in mind the nutritional facts do not contain any mix-ins. This nutrition information provided is calculated based on My Fitness Pal and should be used as a general guide only.

NUTrition Facts: 240 calories | 33g. protein | 17g. carbs | 5g. fat
Print

Butterscotch Ice Cream (Ninja Creami)

Course Dessert
Keyword butterscotch ice cream, ninja creami
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 1 day
Total Time 1 day 5 minutes
Servings 1

Ingredients

  • 1 cup Fairlife 2% Milk
  • 1 scoop Vanilla Protein Powder *I use Clean Simple Eats
  • 1 tbsp. Butterscotch Pudding Mix
  • 1/4 tsp. Jordan's Skinny Gourmet Caramel Syrup (Sugar Free)

Instructions

  1. Take a Ninja Creami pint container and fill it up with all the ingredients.

  2. Next, take your frother and froth until all are combined. If you do not have a frother you can use a blender.

  3. Freeze the mix for about 8-24 hours.

  4. Take the pint out and run it under warm water for 1-2 minutes.

  5. Put it into the Ninja Creami and then blend on “Lite Ice Cream.”

  6. Remove from the Ninja Creami and check to see what it looks like.

  7. If you want it a little more creamy, put it back in the machine and hit “re-spin”.

  8. Check the ice cream as the final result should be creamy in texture.

  9. *If you decide to add mix-ins you can make a hole in the middle, add your mix-ins, and then put the pint back into the machine, and hit "mix-ins".

IF YOU TRIED THIS HOMEMADE BUTTERSCOTCH ICE CREAM PLEASE LEAVE A COMMENT AND STAR RATING! I WOULD LOVE TO KNOW WHAT YOU THINK!

PIN FOR LATER!

butterscotch ice cream recipe idea
ninja creami butterscotch
homemade butterscotch ice cream

Posted In: Blog, Ninja Creami, Recipes

Get on the List

You’ll Also Love

The New Way to Shop for an Engagement Ring!
fall nails 202520 Cute Fall Nail Ideas in 2025
homemade monkey breadHow to Make Delicious Mini Monkey Bread

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Next Post >

Learn How to Make Pretzel Flowers for a Spring Treat

About Me
Welcome to my favorite space, my little corner of the internet where you can pour a hot cup of coffee (or your favorite drink), sit back and spend some time with me!

Cheers!

amazon disclaimer

Leah is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Stay Updated

Featured

Archives

Categories

  • Gift Guides
  • Lifestyle
  • Recipes
  • Wellness

Search

hey there!

Why hello friend! Thanks so much for stopping by and taking the time to get to know me. My name is Leah and I am the girl behind the blog, Lifestyle with Leah. I am also a wife, mommy of two girls, and a serious lover of coffee and red wine. On this blog, I share all of my favorites… family, wellness, recipes, essential oils, tips and tricks, you name it… it’s probably on here! Enjoy!

Work With Me

  • Services
  • Meet Leah
  • Contact

Resources

  • Resources
  • How to Start a Blog
  • Income Reports

Shop

  • Amazon Storefront
  • LTK
  • Etsy
  • Terms and Conditions

Copyright © 2026 Lifestyle with Leah · Theme by 17th Avenue

Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy